The Great Debate Continues… Smooth or Crunchy? Which is YOUR preference? by | 9 comments It’s National Peanut Butter Day! Let’s settle the debate once and for all.Which is best, SMOOTH or CRUNCHY?Take Our Poll 9 Comments MissDazey on 2012/01/24 at I love and live on Peter Pan honey roast creamy. Reply Jeanette on 2012/01/24 at Crunchy! Reply annette baesel on 2012/01/24 at smooth: on fresh cut apples (or celery if apples are not available). yummmy. Reply Claire on 2012/01/25 at Smooth! Reply Matt 'mmWine' Horbund on 2012/10/01 at Im a smooth guy! Reply Rick Griffin on 2012/10/01 at CrUnChY – just like God intended! Reply Lyn @LovelyPantry on 2013/01/24 at Smooth! Reply Candace @ Cabot on 2017/03/15 at The folks at Cabot like both, but sMOOth might be our favorite! Reply Mikki on 2025/08/09 at Depends on the peanut butter. I prefer the only-peanuts-old fashioned-gotta-stir peanut butter and it’s more “mini chunky” but for apples it must be smoooooooth. ReplyLeave a ReplyCancel reply This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
annette baesel on 2012/01/24 at smooth: on fresh cut apples (or celery if apples are not available). yummmy. Reply
Candace @ Cabot on 2017/03/15 at The folks at Cabot like both, but sMOOth might be our favorite! Reply
Mikki on 2025/08/09 at Depends on the peanut butter. I prefer the only-peanuts-old fashioned-gotta-stir peanut butter and it’s more “mini chunky” but for apples it must be smoooooooth. Reply
I love and live on Peter Pan honey roast creamy.
Crunchy!
smooth: on fresh cut apples (or celery if apples are not available). yummmy.
Smooth!
Im a smooth guy!
CrUnChY – just like God intended!
Smooth!
The folks at Cabot like both, but sMOOth might be our favorite!
Depends on the peanut butter. I prefer the only-peanuts-old fashioned-gotta-stir peanut butter and it’s more “mini chunky” but for apples it must be smoooooooth.